Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Time Is Ticking FASSSSSST! Come ON, Do Something!!!


TIME IS TICKING!

Legislators need to know that we need to re-establish the Iowa Film Office and properly fund and staff it! Unless enough of us act, we will have another TWO YEAR wait until another chance presents itself.

Today Jay and I took a letter to the Iowa governor containing accounts of how the axing of the film program hurt Iowans.

From Oregon Capitol News, by Sarah Ross

Film incentives to get another look in the legislature

January 24, 2011

BY SARAH ROSS

PORTLAND- With Oregon’s $7.5 million film incentive program set to expire, the question for legislators remains, how important is keeping the film industry alive in the state?

It’s been present in Oregon since the “Silent Era.” It’s brought in celebrities of high caliber and helped transform little-known stars into household names.

From the most recent success of Portlandia to the location for TNT drama Leverage, the film industry in Oregon has been active for decades and has claimed major successes in just the last few years with the blockbuster Twilight.

But few Oregonians are aware of the work it takes to bring these names to film in the state. With competition from states like Louisiana and Michigan which give away millions more in incentives to bring the industry to their states, even films like Twilight have moved to those locations for continuous production.

“Of the forty-plus states that offer tax incentives, or film incentives, Oregon ranks among the lower third in terms of money that producers can access,” said Vince Porter, Executive Director of the Governor’s Office of Film and Television.

In the recent election, many new fiscal conservative governors have taken these film incentive programs to task as part of their budgetary downsizing. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie even went so far as to eliminate the program in New Jersey all together.

While fiscal conservatives may see the elimination of this program as an easy decision, it does have consequences.

As an example, Porter mentioned that at hearing news of the elimination of New Jersey’s film incentive program, Law and Order SVU immediately uprooted their production to New York state.

“For better or worse, the current environment for film production is that your state needs to have an incentive program in order to get that kind of work,” said Porter.

In the 2009 legislative session, the state legislature passed an increase in funding for the Office to attract production teams to the state. Since that time, the Office has given away $7.5 million in tax rebates each year to projects which spend over $750,000 in the area. The projects are eligible for up to a 20 percent rebate on goods and services purchased in Oregon.

Not only can projects get these rebates on goods and services, but projects which spend at least $1 million locally are given a 16.2 percent cash rebate on wages paid within the state.

To spur growth in the local film industry, the Indigenous Oregon Production Investment Fund was created in 2009 to provide the same 20 percent rebates to Oregon-based projects spending at least $75,000.

The extension of the $7.5 million cap on film incentives is set to expire in the coming year, meaning that a new piece of legislation to adjust that sunset date and extend the cap will be coming down the pipe in the 2011 legislative session.

“I anticipate a debate,” said Porter. “Anybody that has a key program that involves tax credits this year should be ready for a debate.”

“We do have a lot of people…within the legislature who conceptually very much think that this has been a good performing effort and one worth continuing,” he said.

Friday, January 21, 2011

by Dorothy Pomerantz at Forbes.Com

The Improving Economics of Independent Film
Jan. 20 2011
By DOROTHY POMERANTZ

What will be this year's 'Little Miss Sunshine'?

Thousands of people are converging on Park City, Utah, today for the start of the Sundance Film Festival, the biggest independent film festival of the year. Sundance is where films like Little Miss Sunshine, The Usual Suspects and The Blair Witch Project made their debuts.

For the past few years though, Sundance has been at the center of an industry in trouble. Like the rest of the economy, the independent film world got hit hard by the global crisis. Before 2008, Wall Street bankers with more money than they knew what to do with were directing extra funds into the film world in the hopes of turning a profit or at least getting to meet Scarlett Johansson.

That created a glut of independent films that were competing for limited theater space and audience attention. As a result marketing budgets started to exceed production budgets. The economics of making independent films fell apart around the same time Wall Street crashed. Independent film branches like Paramount Vantage and Warner Independent closed their doors.

But today, things are starting to look up for independent films. The glut is gone. And with fewer players, those left standing can focus only on quality films that have box office potential instead of making a grab for any movie with any buzz at all.

And it’s getting easier to finance movies than it was two years ago.

“The amount of equity required to finance a film has diminished,” say Steven Beer, a lawyer at Greenberg Traurig who is helping to sell three films at the festival this year including a documentary about A Tribe Called Quest. “The Jobs Creation Act gives filmmakers a federal tax credit for qualified production. Couple that with state incentive programs which can offer up to a 40% return on a per project basis.”

Plus filmmakers have more outlets than ever to show their films. It was once seen as a Scarlet Letter to have your movie go straight to DVD. But video on demand and streaming through iTunes and Netflix don’t carry the same kind of stigma.

“Theatrical release is no longer the Holy Grail for the independent film community,” says Beer. “You’re better off using a limited release to raise awareness. VOD streaming and digital downloads are much more fertile ground for revenue.”

As part of the Comcast/NBC merger which was approved by the FCC earlier this week, Comcast agreed to work with the Independent Film and Television Alliance to allow for more independently-produced shows and movies on NBC stations. As part of the deal Comcast will meet with the IFTA to help independent producers “license their content to Comcast Cable for distribution on new media platforms.”

And as movies like Black Swan have shown, independent films cam be quite profitable. Made for only an estimated $13 million, the film has so far grossed $76 million. That’s better economics than something like How Do You Know which cost an estimated $120 million and has brought in only $30 million to date.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Gov. Branstad Quote From Beth Malicki Interview

On the Iowa Film Office
"I think it was ill conceived and badly managed that while tax credit- I think that was a mistake."

"I think we can have film in Iowa. I don't think we need to give a big tax break to people who don't live in Iowa and don't pay taxes in Iowa. We need to revamp it. I want to restore the film office. I want to do it in a way that's efficient and economical and I believe that based on that we can attract film. But if we spend more than we benefit, it doesn't make sense."

Monday, January 17, 2011

Back Lot or Industry? - Iowa's Place in the Film Business

When supporters of an Iowa Film Incentive talk, it is usually along these lines: "We need film incentives so film producers (Hollywood) will come to Iowa, shoot their films, spend money, and support the Iowa Film Industry". They usually talk and think of Iowa as solely a location. They speak of economic impact in terms of purchases at local businesses. All this is well and good but it certainly does not create an industry, at least not a permanent one. This is because if the flow of films ebbs, those Iowans working in the business will have to either go elsewhere to seek opportunities or find another line of work.

Regarding Iowa as strictly a shooting location and placing ourselves entirely at the whims of the production slate of Hollywood studios is a very limiting way of thinking. To consider Iowa as being exclusively a location brings a few problems and limitations with it. Weather is one of them. Most productions are likely to be shooting during the warmer months of the year. This leaves film workers idle during the winter months.

When considering Iowa as a location most producers imagine only farms and small towns. This hardly makes Iowa unique as there are similar farms and similar small towns in other states and in Canada.

Even in thinking of Iowa as just a location, the thinking is limited because Iowa encompasses more than farms and small towns. There are many wooded areas that could stand in for other locations (think "Robin Hood"). There are areas with sheer rock faces (the bluffs along the Mississippi), and places with tall buildings (Des Moines and Cedar Rapids). Beyond that, most people forget that it is possible to build sets to represent other places. For example, for the film "Aaseamah's Journey" an Iraqi village was built. That's right, in Iowa! Just because this is Iowa doesn't mean that filmmaking with imagination can't happen.

About this "film industry" of ours: Although many call it such, presently it is made up of just a few small companies that produce local and regional television commercials and industrial films. This hardly qualifies us as a mecca for film production. Having feature film productions come in from Hollywood is unlikely to change this much. What is needed is our own indigenous film industry - one with projects that originate within our own borders. If any of these achieve success it may be enough to create the conditions to build permanent businesses and infrastructure.

The film business is not just camera crews on location. There are other facets of the business that function before, during, and after principal photography. Most of these functions are not dependent on locations (mountains, deserts, oceans) or weather and many could certainly be in Iowa.

Functions that take place before shooting and could be anywhere include, and are not limited to, screenwriting, storyboards, film completion bonds, insurance, and budgeting. Why couldn't some of these activities take place in Iowa? Being in close geographic proximity is not as much of an issue as it once was because of technological improvements with communication.

During principal photography, not everything needed is location dependent. During the days of the studio system, sound stages were heavily used and many films today still employ sound stages for part of their production. Because sound stages offer more precise control over shooting conditions and protection from weather, they would be an ideal addition to Iowa's film infrastructure. Besides augmenting the needs of visiting Hollywood productions, they could also make it possible to produce Iowa originated productions year round. If some stages were built with unique characteristics, such as an extra large studio tank, or special equipment for green screen or motion capture, it might be possible for Iowa to attract some movie business that doesn't involve farm and small town locations.

Sound stages also encourage television production. Television shows would be good for the Iowa film community because they typically employ film workers for longer periods of time than feature films and thus provide more stable employment. Television should not be ignored when we talk about a film industry.

A film doesn't end when the cameras stop rolling. There are many processes needed to finish a film and there is no reason they can't happen in Iowa. Films need to be edited, sound mixed, and color corrected. Films need to be scored and, if it is not released digitally, lab work must be done. Why can't at least some of this be available in Iowa?

Lastly a completed film must be marketed and distributed. Distribution is where the real power lies in the industry and it is the function that completes the production chain. Why not have some distribution companies in Iowa? The established companies may have most of the advantages but nothing ever stays the same. With imagination Iowa could have a piece of this business. With distribution in place we could say we truly have a film industry.

So what is Iowa's place in the film business? Back lot or industry?

Sunday, January 16, 2011

What NOT to do with the Iowa Film Incentives

There's been a flurry of activity lately behind the scenes regarding bringing the Iowa Film Incentives back. With the scandals that caused the current program to be suspended there's a strong effort underway to get things right this time. This would be by replacing the current program with a new and improved one. The hope is to eliminate the omissions and remove loopholes that allowed the program to be abused. Many of the steps to take or not take are obvious. But there are a few things to avoid that look good at first glance but are likely to prove troublesome in practice.

Here are some things to avoid doing:

Shifting most of the film credits to higher budget ($25 million and up) productions.

On this surface this idea looks really good. The bigger the production, the more people hired, right? When you look closer to the wide range effects, some problems emerge. Because so much money is at stake on these higher dollar projects producers will tend to cover their bets by hiring already established industry professionals for the more important and high paying positions. For the most part these people will be those from the major production centers (Hollywood and New York, mostly). Because of their proximity to these locals these people are going to have much longer resumes and deeper experience than the average Iowan can hope to get right now. The result of this is that for most Iowans the most likely areas they will be hired for is for the low end and low paying jobs such as Production Assistant or Extra. This would hardly bring in the influx of income that a film program would be expected to bring in.

Smaller productions, although lower paying and requiring closer supervision, do offer a greater chance of advancement than the big films. This can translate into better jobs on the larger budget shows when these people get hired there. It also improves the quality of Iowa's film talent pool making the state a more attractive place to shoot a motion picture or television production.

Another potential benefit of supporting smaller productions is that some of these can be locally originated. If some of these become successes it is possible that some of these producers may want to put down roots, building infrastructure so they can continue to make films in Iowa. Why? Because we as a state supported them, hardly the situation they would find out in L.A.

Big films can be good and they can be exciting but let's not ignore the big producers of tomorrow.


Giving film incentives for using an Iowa-based pass-thru company

A producer can't find the people or equipment they need in Iowa. So they are allowed film credits if they use an Iowa-based pass-thru company to act as a go-between to procure what they need. Sounds like a way of getting things established, doesn't it? Since Iowa doesn't have a sufficient talent pool built up to staff these film jobs the state can still make itself attractive by offering a way around. And therein lies the problem.

Tell me if I'm wrong but isn't the idea of the film incentives to create film employment for Iowans, in addition to the purchase of goods and services - to build an industry, not just to simply bring films into Iowa?

Pass-thru companies are perceived by the public to be a financial shell game - a cheap accounting trick - because, if you look closely, that's exactly what they are - a way of laundering money paid out so that companies can still receive film credits that they would not otherwise receive. Because they are using an Iowa-based go-between to do their procuring of crew and equipment they are rewarded. Outside of the very few Iowans running these pass-thru companies, no Iowans benefit from these transactions.

Instead of training Iowans for important jobs, pass-thru companies allow producers to be still rewarded for not hiring our citizens. Instead of encouraging Iowa-based film support businesses to develop and grow, these pass-thru companies instead
benefit the established players in other states.


Keeping information about films that are set to shoot a secret

While it might be understandable to keep some information about a film production confidential - contracts, casting decisions, budget information (except perhaps that which which involves film credits) - it is not so understandable that the existence of a film and its contact information should be hidden from the Iowa public. Somehow this issue has never come up, but when the typical Iowan, the kind without personal industry connections, finds out about a production being shot, it is already too late. The crew positions are already filled and the film is already cast. The Iowa Film Incentive Program is supposed to give opportunities to all interested Iowans, not just a few select insiders, right?

If any of the above things are included in a new Film Incentive Program there is sure to be trouble ahead and we might not have a chance to recover again.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011


Tonight I attended a meet 'n' greet for Iowa Legislators, which was held at the downtown Des Moines Quality Inn. I went with Jay Villwock, who reluctantly drove, and our friend Dave Thrasher. We were able to have conversations with Shawn Hamerlinck, Republican Senator from Dixon, Iowa. Scott and Nathaniel Weiser, lobbyists. Wally Horn, Democratic Senator from Cedar Rapids. Republican Senator Brad Zaun, from Urbandale.

Everyone we spoke with had only positive things to say about moviemaking in Iowa. Some said people like to have movies made here, that it was exciting and fun. Some offered tips as to how to approach the legislature in order to better sell the idea of making the film office a success again. Next week and during each week the legislature is in session, Jay and I will return to the Iowa Capitol and talk to legislative leaders in our drive to keep filmmaking alive in Iowa.

(pictured from last year's session: me, jay, dave, and Senator Hamerlinck)